book excerptise:   a book unexamined is not worth having

A History of Modern Japan

Richard Storry

Storry, Richard;

A History of Modern Japan

Penguin Books, 1969, 300 pages

ISBN 014020475X

topics: |  japan | history


A compact yet insightful history.  Also very clearly written, though a bit
dry. 

Excerpts

Korean Influence; Importation Of The Chinese Script p.28-29


In the middle of the fourth century, an empress named Jingo organized,
and, it is said, took command of, a military expedition to Korea... 
[not the etym < jingoism]
The expedition resulted in the establishment of a Japanese colony on the tip
of the Korean peninsula.

For the Japanese, the Korean connexion was to have tremendous
consequences. Of these the most striking was undoubtedly the
introduction of the Chinese script. The Japanese language is now so
intimately associated with the use of this script that it is easy to
overlook the really formidable technical difficulties that were involved
in establishing this association. In their spoken forms Chinese and
Japanese differ profoundly. Pure Japanese is a deliciously polysyllabic
tongue. Chinese is monosyllabic. The syntax of one language has nothing
in common with the other. For this reason, no doubt, the use of Chinese
ideographs spread only slowly in Japan. It is probable that the Chinese
script was known to some people in Japan as early as the first century
A.D. but the official adoption of the script is usually dated from the
beginning of the fifth century, and a great many years were to pass
before it became known beyond a narrow circle of scribes attached to the
ruling imperial family. ...

Entire communities of Koreans came to settle in Japan; and they included
skilled artisans, such as workers in metals and experts in the culture
of silkworms. By the middle of the sixth c. there were more than 100,000
Koreans, and Chinese from Manchuria, domiciled in Japan. For the most
part they were much better educated -- either in the literary sense or in
their knowledge of artistic or technical skills -- than the Japanese
among whom they lived and with whom in course of time they were to be
assimilated... Their qualitative importance can be gauged from the fact
that by the opening of the eighth century more than one-third of the
noble families of Japan claimed continental descent, Korean or Chinese.

Receiving so much from Korea, and through Korea, from China, the
Japanese were hardly able or ready to exclude from their shores a
continental religion that was soon to compete with the indigenous
religion [Shinto], though the two would, in the end, complement each
other. The religion was Buddhism, and its arrival in Japan can be dated
from about the middle of the sixth century.

Buddhism never supplanted Shinto. After Buddhism was firmly established
and widely disseminated most Japanese were both Buddhists and
Shintoists, as they are today. In time those who felt the need of some
philosophical justification for such dualism... were able to claim that
after all, the Shinto deities were bodhisattvas and that therefore the
two religions were fundamentally identical.

--
p.168: [After the Tokyo earthquake of 1923 Sept 1] a rumour spread,
almost as fast as the raging fires, that Korean nationalists, together
with Japanese Communists, had plotted to set up some kind of
revolutionary government. As a result many inoffensive Koreans were
sought out and killed by frenzied mobs or by gangs of self-styled
"patriotic" young men.

Historical Terms


Sei-i tai-shogun: barbarian suppressing great general. - p.39
	[Awarded to Minamoto Yoritomo in 1192 by the emperor, a boy of 13.
	From this time it became an office, as opposed to a title in war.
	"In this sense Yoritomo was the first shogun, or 'generalissimo'.]]

Bakufu: Camp office - associated over time with the center of the
	shogunate or military government. Kamakura Bakufu, 150 years after
	Yoritomo. Yedo bakufu - Tokugawa period, 1603-1853.

kamikaze - divine wind. In 1281, a 150,000 strong Mongol armada
	invaded Japan. After a beachhead battle in Kyushu for 53 days, a
	typhoon wiped out the Mongols and their vessels. Since this was
	seen as the result of prayers in shrines across the land, it was
	called kamikaze. - p.41

mabiki - thinning out, as with young rice plants. In the context of
	Tokugawa Japan which saw great hardships to the peasantry, this
	meant exposing unwanted babies to the elements - "The typical
	farmhouse could not feed more than a certain number of mouths."
	- p.76

jingo: Name of Japanese empress who organized, and, it is said, took
	command of, a military expedition against Korea. mid-4th c.

junshi: When a ruler or great lord died certain of his retainers
	killed themselves so they might escort him to the next world.
	(General Nogi, victor of Port Arthur in the Russo-J war,
	committed junshi after the death of Meiji.) - p.149

Moga: Moga was the Japanese contraction of the English words, 'modern
	girl'. It came to suggest, during the twenties, cloche hats and
	short skirts, with the 'bob', 'shingle', or even the 'Eton crop.'

Mobo: The 'modern boy', who on leaving the university adopted the
	latest and most flashy Western clothes including, it might be,
	'Oxford bags'. Occasionally Mobo and Moga might be seen walking
	down the Ginza hand in hand. This was very daring; but it was
	done.	- p. 166

fukoku kyohei - rich country and strong army

daimyo - "great name" - feudal lord

hakama - samurai dress skirt; chomage - samurai topknot p.103

minken - people's rights p.113

narikin - new rich - profiteers

Meiji: 1866-1912

Taisho: "Great righteousness" - name adopted by emperor after Meiji
	(1912) . - p.149


Perry's Expedition


Four factors combined to stimulate American interest in Japan. These
were the development of trade with China through Canton, the growth of
the American whaling industry in the Pacific, the opening-up of
California, symbolized by the Gold Rush of 1849, and the progress of
steam navigation. The Great Circle Route, the shortest to China from the
Pacific coast of America, took vessels very close to, and often in sight
of, the shores of Japan. ...

One of the purposes of Perry's expedition was to obtain a promise from
the Japanese of future good treatment of any shipwrecked Americans.
But ... it may be doubted whether the treatment of American nationals
in Japan played more than a minor part in the motives behind Commodore
Perry's visit to Japan in the summer of 1853. Of much more importance
was, for example, the need to secure supplies, including coal, for
American ships sailing to and from Canton.  There was too, the
expectation that a useful trade could be driven with the closed
country, and expectation sharpened by the prospect of competition from
Great Britain. ... Nobody was more active [towards authorizing a naval
expedition] than a certain Arthur E Palmer, an energetic new York
commission agent profoundly interested in the steamship trade with the
Orient. Similar pressure on Congress came from churches, missionary
boards, diplomats, and naval officers.  p.85-86

[After Perry, accompanied by two steamships unheard of in Japan, left a
letter in 1853, the Japanese decided on a policy of peaceful "no
definite answer." However, on Perry's return the next February with
seven ships, a treaty was signed in Yokohama opening two ports, Shimoda
in the south and Hakodate in Hokkaido, to American traffic, and agreeing
to a consul in one of them. This consul, Townsend Harris, playing on
Japanese fears of British intrusion, managed to sign a further treaty in
June 1857 for extra-territorial rights to American citizens in Japan,
and for permanent residence to Americans in both these ports. In Dec
1857, he also managed a much resisted audience with the shogun, whose
response was interpreted to Harris thus:
	"Pleased with the letter sent with the Ambassador from a far distant
	country, and likewise pleased with the discourse. Intercourse shall
	be continued for ever."

The Meiji restoration


Knowledge shall be sought for all over the world and thus shall be
strengthened the foundation of the imperial polity.
	- Emperor Meiji's 'Charter Oath,' April 1868 - p.103

For among the Japanese there has never been the disdainful indifference
that has often characterized the Chinese attitude towards foreigners.
The Japanese have always been proud to learn.
	- p.104

There is no soil within the empire that does not belong to the
Emperor... and no inhabitant who is not a subject of the Emperor, though
in the Middle Ages, the Imperial power declined and the military classes
rose, taking possession of the land and dividing it among themselves as
the prize of their bow and spear. But now that the Imperial power is
restored, how can we retain possession of land that belongs to the
Emperor and govern people who are his subjects? We therefore reverently
offer up all our feudal possessions... so that a uniform rule may
prevail throughout the Empire. Thus the country will be able to rank
equally with the other nations of the world.

    - Memorial addressed to the emperor by lords of the four western
	fiefdoms, 1868-69. Probably drafted by Kido Koin from Choshu.
	Marks the end of the feudal structure in Japan, and also the
	willingness of the controllers of power to put the country above
	personal interests.  p.105

Japanese imitativeness has always alternately irritated and amused the
West. But to learn is to copy. For a backward country, technological
progress must be based of necessity upon imitation. - p.106

[growth of jingoism] The idea of Japanese expansion grew in proportion
to the spread of mass education. - p.113

[1872] The educational plan called for the establishment of nearly
54,000 elementary schools -- or roughly one to every 600 inhabitants --
and the result fifty years later was that the Japanese became what they
still are -- the most highly literate people in Asia
	- p.113. (If not the world!) [Also see "The J that can say no"]

The progress of education, together with the system of conscription,
moulded the people into a nation of patriots. - p.113

... that sublimated form of civil war, party politics. p.112

The first sentence of the Japanese Constitution of 1889, framed for the
most part by Ito Hirbumi, based on visits by him to to several European
countries, especially Bismarck's Germany: Japan 'shall be reigned over
and governed by a line of Emperors unbroken for ages eternal.'

Towards the end of the eighties there developed a pronounced revival of
Confucian sentiment within the governing class, in reaction to the
passion for Western things and ideas. This was reflected in the famous
Rescript on Education, promulgated by the emperor in 1890, which
acquired, as was intended ... the authority of holy writ ... a copy of
the rescript, together with portraits of the emperor and his consort,
was kept by every school in a secure place -- in many schools this was
in fact a small shrine -- and was brought out on days of national
commemoration to be read aloud by the college or school principal with
great reverence to a respectful assembly of pupils. The rescript adjured
the children and young people of Japan to observe the Confucian
obligations of filial piety, obedience, and benevolence in their various
relationships and to offer themselves 'courageously to the State' should
emergency arise... the prestige of this document in the eyes of the
masses can scarcely be exaggerated. - p.119

---

I'm glad I was injured by a progressive western invention and not by a
sword or some such old-fashioned device.
    - Shigenobu Okuma, Japanese foreign minister, injured in a bomb attack
        1889.

Business Growth


In its determination to build up 'a rich country and a strong army' the
government never considered leaving industrial development to private
initiative... New industries could not be nourished behind a high wall
of protective duties, for thanks to the treaty system Japan was
restricted to a scale of low tariffs. - p.121

The zaibatsu were the chief beneficiaries of a policy adopted by
the government some years after the Restoration. Having promoted and
managed new industrial enterprises, the government handed most of them
over, at almost ridiculously low rates, to a few private companies,
[which became the zaibatsu]. Since they owed so much to the
government, they were bound to it by ties of obligation that Japanese
have always found difficult to break; and in any case there was
ususlally a close identity of interests between the zaibatsu and the
political oligarchy... On the other hand, business rivalries among
these financial cliques - between Mitsui and Mitsubishi for example -
led them to be very closely associated with certain individual members
of the oligarchy. - p. 123

Shinko-zaibatsu: new business groups that grew in Manchuria out
of the army's professed socialist stance and its dislike of the
established zaibatsu that had become aligned with the parties, Mitsui
with the Seiyukai and Mitsubishi with Minseito. [p.172] The army
encouraged new groups, such as Nissan, that flourished after the army
expansionism in Manchukuo and Inner Mongolia. After the UN
condemnation of this move, Japan left the League of Nations. [p.193-4]

---

[The 'Triple Intervention' was a concession won by Russia, France and
  Germany, from Japan after it won some valuable prizes after its
  adventurism against China in the Korean peninsula, including the
  Liaotung peninsula with the fortress of Port Arthur. Three days after
  the Treaty of Shimonoseki (1895) Liaotung was surrendered by Japan
  under the advise of the ministers of the three western nations since
  it was a threat to the 'peace of the East'.]
There was massive popular indignation against the action of Russia,
France, and Germany. But the Emperor Meiji told his people that they
must bear the unbearable - his grandson used the same words in 1945 -
and the command was obeyed. [the western nations, which had been
respected, were now] distrusted, despised even, as hypocrites. For
within five years, Germany seized Tsingtau, France secured the lease
of Kwangchow Bay, and Great Britain the lease of Wei-hai-wei and Hong
Kong, and Russia obtained control of Port Arthur and the Liaotung
Peninsula.  - p.127

I will be the word of the people. I will be the bleeding mouth
from which the gag has been snatched. I will say everything.
	- p.147,  Katayama Sen, in a socialist periodical

After 1915 [diplomatic bullying of China] Japan never recovered, in
the eyes of the American people, the moral prestige - so high in 1905
- that was lost at that time. From now on it was Japan that was cast
in the role of the bully; and even when the Japanese behaved well
towards China, as they did at various times during the 1920s, they
never got the credit for it. In terms of propaganda the Chinese ...
swept the field.
	- p.154

The rich were now much despised; and the prime minister had lost his
early popularity, being regarded, unfairly perhaps, as sharing some
responsibility for corruption scandals affecting at least three of his
cabinet ministers as well as a number of members of the Diet. (1921)
	- p.161

The late Taisho and early Showa periods - the twenties - are often
referred to by the Japanese as the era of "Ero, Guro, Nansensu" -
namely, eroticism, grotesquerie, and nonsense. - p.166

Dissidence


[Saigo Takamori was a legendary 'patriot' from Satsuma, who resigned
from govt and eventually led an armed rebellion manned by the Samurai
class against the conscripted Imperial army led by Yamagata Aritomo of
Choshu, who was to remain a leading national figure on the right for
decades. After 30K casualties on both sides, the rebellion was
suppressed and] Saigo, wounded, was beheaded on the battlefield, at
his own request, by a close friend. ... From his point of view, of
course, Saigo's armed protest was no rebellion. He was not resisting
the imperial will, for this was misdirected by 'evil advisors'...
	- p.111-112.

[Chang Tso-Lin, warlord of Manchuria, killed in rly carriage explosion
1928?, part of an adventurist plot by Japanese officers to seize
Manchria without authorization]. When Tanaka [PM] discovered what had
taken place he was eager, with the full support of the emperor, to
have those concerned tried and punished, by court-martial if
necessary. In fact the emperor was profoundly disturbed, and this
added to Tanaka's anxieties; for he found that the Chief of the
General Staff and other senior officers were stubbornly opposed to any
severe disciplinary action being taken... on the grounds that it would
harm the prestige of the army.  And so indiscipline was overlooked and
another evil precedent established. - p.176

[March Incident: A coup d'etat was planned in 1931 to install the
minister of War, General Ugaki, the PM in a military government, but
was abandoned after Ugaki indicated his unequivocal disapproval.] Some
senor officers were implicated, besides the young hot-heads. The
example they set was deplorable; and as these senior officers held key
appointments (one of them was Vice-Chief of the General Staff) it
seemed almost out of the question that they should be punished for
their part in a conspiracy that was, after all, abandoned. ... Efforts
were made to hush up the entire affair, and so indiscipline of a most
dangerous kind was totally condoned.  - p.180

kurai tanima - the dark valley. The period between 1931 and 1941, the
	decade immediately preceding the outbreak of the Pacific war.

gekokujo - the overpowering of seniors by juniors.

[The prospect of insubordination / civil war] horrified senior
officers and cabinet ministers, causing them to shrink from the really
firm action that was required... and found themselfes in a position
of being in effect blackmailed by the threats of a lunatic fringe of
'Young Turks' - p.184

[A plot for liquidating the govt in one blow by bombing from the air
was hatched in 1933. Luckily, it was foiled just in time.] No mention
was made of the affair until 1935, two years after it had occurred.
The trial of the accused did not begin until 1937 and was not
completed until 1941. when a judgement was given that (in the words of
the Japan Times) was 'a triumph of law in Japan and a briliiant piece
of political adjustment'. The accused received short terms of
imprisonment, with immediate remission of sentence. - p.196

February 1936 Mutiny


During the early hours of 26 February 1936, in a severe snowstorm,
detachments from two infantry regiments of the First Division,
together with some sympathizers from the Guards Division, left their
barracks. They split [up and attacked many] public men; and before
daylight there were some terrible scenes as doors were forced and the
victims, nearly all of them old men, shot down. Admiral Okada [PM]
escaped death, his brother-in-law being mistaken for him. Two former
premiers, Saito and Takahashi, and Mazaki's successor as Inspector
General were killed. The Grand Chamberlain, Admiral Suzuki, was
dangerously wounded and was left to die. ... An effort was made to
catch the aged Saionji at his country villa; but he got word in
advance and was not at home. ... There was no officer above the rank
of captain. - p. 199

[see John Toland's detailed description of Okada's survival]

In the universities conformist pressure, though in some ways less
directly overpowering, made it increasingly hazardous for academic
staff to retain the self-respect that comes from intellectual
integrity. - p.195.

[In the extensive aerial incendiary bombing of early 1945, all the
cities were laid waste except for Kyoto.] For mile after mile the huge
urban area from Tokyo throught Kawasaki to Yokohoma presented the
spectacle of charred wood and ashes with scarcely a building standing.
... Among the large cities only Kyoto was untouched - thanks, it is
said, to persistent representations in Washington by the Curator of
the Boston Museum of Fine Arts. -p.228

Surrender address by the emperor


"The war situation has developed not necessarily to Japan's advantage.
... We have resolved to pave the way for a grand peace for all the
generations to come by enduring the unendurable and suffering what is
insufferable." - p.237

Close on midnight on 14 August 1945, the emperor recorded his rescript
terminating the war. It was to be broadcast the following day.

In the very early hours of 15 August an attempt was made to seize and
destroy this record. ... They proceeded to surround the palace and
search anxiously for the record. This they were unable to find.
Meanwhile, word [reached the] headquarters in Tokyo and the general in
command very courageously went at once to the palace. By the sheer force
of his personality and the eloquence of what he said ... he persuaded
the insurgent leaders that they had behaved in a wholly wrong-headed
manner. They admitted their error, and four of them committed suicide on
the spot. -p.236

The constitution of 1946


[MacArthur's SCAP (Sup Commdr Allied Powers) told the government] that
the constitution would have to be amended very radically and that this
ought to be done as quickly as possible. Accordingly the Shidehara
cabinet appointed a committee to draft the necessary revisions; but
its suggestions did not satisfy General Headquarters. They did not go
far enough ... towards removing the undemocratic principles expressed
and implied in the Meiji Constitution. So MacArthur's own staff
produced a document, in effect an entirely new Constitution, and this
was ... [under a verbal ultimatum] accepted by the Diet with only
minor alterations.

--bio
Richard Storry was a fellow of St Antony's College, Oxford


amitabha mukerjee (mukerjee [at-symbol] gmail.com) 2011 Feb 18