book excerptise:   a book unexamined is not worth having

Ploughshares Spring 2008

B.H. Fairchild (ed.)

Fairchild, B.H. (ed.);

Ploughshares Spring 2008

Emerson College, 2008 Paperback

ISBN 9781933058092

topics: |  poetry | anthology | usa


As I was leafing through the enormous piles of 1$ books outside the Strand
Bookstore in Manhattan, I chanced upon this magazine, and in it, on Bruce
Bond's Ringtone.  A bit more riffling found Elizabeth Bradfield'
Phrenology (just the conception is worth it, though isn't as stark and
startling).  At 1$, of course, I bought the book (or magazine?)

Maybe it is a law of expectation.  In the end, most of the poems didn't seem
that strong - but on the whole it had a far higher than average incidence of
good poems.

Ploughshares is one of America's leading literary magazines, there
is only so much good poetry coming out, really fresh. 

After I'd typed in Ringtone, I realized that almost all the poems are
available at  http://www.pshares.org/issues/issues.cfm?intissueid=126

Bruce Bond: Ringtone

As they loaded the dead onto the gurneys
to wheel them from the univesity halls,
who could have predicted the startled chirping
in those pockets, the invisible bells
and tiny metal music of the phones,
in each the cheer of a voiceless song.
Pop mostly, Timberlake, Shakira, tunes
never more various now, more young,
shibboleths of what a student hears,
what chimes in the doorway to the parent
on the line.  Who could have answered there
in proxy for the dead, received the panic
with grace, however artless, a live bird
gone still at the meeting of the strangers.
     http://www.pshares.org/issues/article.cfm?prmarticleID=8830
#roustabout

Betty Adcock: Roustabout


I was twenty-two, pretty maybe. It was a small town
county fair: hot dogs, freak show, cotton candy,
and heavy wheels laden with light,
all tuned to the gaudy air.

The Octopus—remember that one? Eight
arms like extended girders, the thing was a metal
Shiva juggling worlds: a cup spun at the end
of each madly oscillating arm, every cup
overfull of squealing kids or lovers drunk
on the whip-sharp unexpected torque
toward the expected rapture.

He was maybe twenty, bare-chested, tanned
and gleaming in the southern September night,
a kind of summer in the lights that played
across him as he pulled levers set to arm
the bright contraption with speed and plunge,
with whirl and rise. His hair was almost red
in the lights’ translation. Not many
riders yet, when suddenly he leapt
onto one of the metal arms in its low sweep
and rose with it. And laughed.

I thought it might be for me, this showing
off. He jumped onto the next arm as it rose,
went up with it, then landed easy on the ground.
He vaulted the lowered ones as they went by,
stepped up again, and down again, then ducked
under so a steel arm grazed his cap. How long
ago it was.
How long did I stand and watch
that wild control before I turned
to find my husband and child?

He’s likely dead now, or deep asleep
in some wine-dark room, some ragged dream.
I think no golden years follow that life,
though I can still see him shining new
against black sky and turning stars—
chancing it, taking on the monster,
winning, dancing it.

Elizabeth Bradfield: Phrenology


Were the earth a skull, the lump
at its base would read to Victorian
doctors as amativeness: connubial
love, procreative lust. And where the peninsula

stretches up toward Patagonia
a smidge of philoprogenitiveness,
parental love, a fondness for pets
and the generally helpless. Jules Dumont d’Urville,

man of his times, had his own skull mapped
before sailing to map earth’s southern blur.
Were the earth a skull and someone
with knowledge laid hands on it, felt topography

for expression of its psyche, would this
answer what questions are asked
in slog and observation, in sample and ice core?

Sub-Antarctic islands bulge at the spot
of combativeness: self-defense, a go-to
disposition and love of debate. Aimentiveness
at South Africa and New Zealand: appetite,

an enjoyment of food and drink. Jules
was pleased with what the doctor found,
felt himself seen truly. But what judges
our human descriptions of place?

Weather? Lichens? The transitory animals
that touch upon it? Were the earth a skull,
were its bones shaped by humors,
were understanding so palpable, so constant.

Gregory Fraser: Silverfish


Pressed between print, haunting gutters, we traded closeness
for dialogue and plot, dropped concordantly to sleep

not long before dawn, hardbacks propped on our chests
like tents on a plain in Cooper. Wingless, piscatorial,

we dined on starches and molds, slid into cracks, crevices,
bathtubs on occasion. Troubled to escape their slick,

enameled palisades, we chose the horizontal: Leaves of Grass
in lounge chairs by the pool, Ginsberg on blow-up rafts.

Our rooms, bibliographic amphitheaters, thronged
with titled spines. The Odyssey, The Frogs, Collected Verse

of John Crowe Ransom. We burrowed in Woolf,
gnawed Updike and Austen, all of whom declared,

The first sorrow can be lifted but not hauled off—
a theme we paid too little notice, paying ransom to it,

as we were, for and with our lives. During famine,
we attacked the leatherware: fine-bound collector’s copies.

Naturally, we considered children nymphs, creatures
of liquid and myth. A decade’s passed since last

we kissed. Were we mistaken to embrace,
or simply overtaken by aversions to the real?

One time, in a viscid afternoon no one but us recalls,
I climbed the broken back of a sweet-gum tree

while you snapped photos, unmindful of your thumb
obscuring the lens. One can block a part of the heart,

you know. You know, Lepisma saccharina,
sweet tooth, old friend of sizing and glue. Thankfully,

the damage we did, commensurate with our kind,
was slight—minor foxing of silks and rayon.

Yet I sometimes think we might have flourished
had we canoed the Susquehanna, or submitted

to the balms of church. Studious, antennae raised,
we sought protection in exacted meaning, forced

our minds to mind and called the act reflection.
It didn’t help. Lost in leitmotifs, humidities

of simmering conflict, we came to begrudge
the characters we consumed—their crafted shapeliness,

perfect aim at fate. Who could blame us in our supple
exoskeletons, lank appendages? We had to part.

Like every paradise, ideal companionship exists purely
on the page, is the page. Here. For old times. Feed on this.

Allen Grossman: The Garden Oak


1.
Once more. My obligation to my mind
requires that I speak in the only way
it understands.—This time, of the oldest tree
remembered, the garden oak in its mysterious well

which utters still, each spring—after winter
and all its snows—new branches, and on them
leaves. Then flowers—and, then its proper seeds,
each acorn in a cup, each also an oak

to be remembered, an oak in just such
a remembered garden as this one is.
Sit down with me. I have more to say...
And there is honor in finding the words.

2.
NOTE! I am not a speaker of your kind.
No one you hear is a speaker of your kind.
The first poet I knew, my only master, was
not human, not a speaker of our kind.

Honor is repeating words good enough—
mute, eloquent, and true—as uttered by the garden
oak, rooted in its mysterious well, when the wind
rose up and the oak uttered words, and taught.

Whatever I may have said to you, or to
another (it’s now fifty years of saying),
whatever in or around the words seems
for a moment true, is of no account unless

3.
you hear the oak say it too. Such is the way,
reason of rememembering. Listen! It is not I
who speak. You do not attend to me, alone.
Above us both, above each one, the master

of winters rooted in a mysterious well,
makes words known.—Something knocks at the window.
It is thought of the world without intention,
without naming and without a name, or

the idea of name. Now it is brought to mind—
enormous sway, without love or intention to love.
All my life, I sit in the shadow of the oak,
spectator of its changes—and the weather.

4.
Come out with me and feel the enormous sway
of one will that’s free. Although dark and rain
shroud body and soul. Although you are weary
and cold as hell, be patient with my words

and sing along with me. I am like you.
You are like me—on the same road—and each
of us has a story. We are not free.
Nor are we slaves. We are not lost. Not found.

There is a tree we know—the two of us—
the garden oak, rooted in a mysterious well.
Under that tree, master of seasons, sit down
a moment. Consider. Then go your way.

Stephen Dunn: To a Friend Accused of a Crime He May Have Committed


We’ll never know for sure now,
you in your garage with the motor on
and the tailpipe clogged and the door closed,
three days before the trial. Your wife
found you after she found the note,
and this morning the numinous beauty
of low fog in our field has taken on
a strange gloom, a lone deer grazing there
with an alertness that you must have had
many days of your life, lest you be caught.

For twenty-five years we knew you
to be a man who could charm a room,
yet stand up at a faculty meeting
and press an argument, not back down.
When we dined with you, you loved
to tell us all the places you’d been.
How stupid of you to allow
your computer to be repaired,
the hard facts on the hard drive—
all those boys, girls, this other life.

What brilliance, though, to have concealed it
for so long. And how nearby desperation
always must have been. I’ll remember your face
now as a thing with a veil, what I so admire
in poker players. You were not one of those.
When word first got out, we called you,
said we were there for you. In our minds
you remained a friend. We didn’t call again.
When does a friend cease being a friend?
After which betrayal, yours or ours?
Or do we just go on in the muck and the mud
holding ourselves up the best we can?
That’s what we’re asking ourselves,
the fog lifting a little, the newspaper
with your photo in it open on our table.

Contents

INTRODUCTION
B. H. Fairchild		Introduction 			7
EDITOR PROFILE
Rebecca Morgan Frank	About B. H. Fairchild 	 	192

FICTION
Barbara Dimmick		Honeymoon 			46
Christie Hodgen		Tom & Jerry 			68
William Lychack		Stolpestad 			105
Maile Meloy		Agustín 			125
Gerald Shapiro		Mandelbaum, the Criminal 	153
NONFICTION
James Brown		Missing the Dead 		22
Alexis Wiggins		Unanimal 			180

POETRY
Betty Adcock		Roustabout 			11
	[she remembers a worker at a country fair,
		I was twenty-two, pretty maybe. It was a small town
		county fair: hot dogs, freak show, cotton candy,
	he was showing off on the giant wheel - was it for her?
			the southern September night,
		a kind of summer in the lights that played
		across him as he pulled levers set to arm
		the bright contraption with speed and plunge,
		with whirl and rise. His hair was almost red
		in the lights’ translation.
	as a twist, she has to leave "to find my husband and child".]

William Baer		Motes 				13
	["detritus of the universe" "hovering in the shafts of the morning
	air" A "suffocating sea / of sunlit dust that pins him to bed."
	the end, with the eyes "clogged with motes", didn't work for me.]

William Baer		The Puzzle House 		14
	[
		“I think you think I don’t know who you are,”
		she says at the window, “but I know what I know.”
	she no longer recognizes people, (possibly her son).  She's been
	doing a jigsaw puzzle, of Escher's Waterfall.  Clozapine and
	stimulants give hope, but in the end, there is no recognition.]

Christopher Bakken	Drunk 				15
	[memories of a friend who got drunk in his Impala; didn't work for me]

George Bilgere		Muscle 				17
        [memories of muscle cars, "Cougars, Mustangs, GTOs."
        rumbling off "for no particular reason" -
		When suddenly,
                       through a dirty, underhanded
 	 	trick of time, I’m turning gray

                at a table in front of Starbucks.
		       Sipping a latte, talking mortgage
		with a woman I seem to be married to.

		A silly little Prius
                        scoots by without a sound,
 	 	followed by a bleak Insight. ]

Michelle Boisseau	Eighteenth-Century Boisseau House 	18
	[An old house, "snaggle-toothed shutters", shirts on a clothesline
         become chickens (mass or count noun?).  Technically well-crafted,
         but the excitement is not there. ]

Michelle Boisseau	Monstrance 			19
	 [MONSTRANCE = step-by-step proof <- demonstration;
	 Good with the innovative turn of phrase
	 	"Cranky and cratered, I maneuver
	  	like a moon of bright remarks."
 	 but overall the theme does not gel that strongly. ]

Bruce Bond		Ringtone 			20
	[One of the most powerful poems in this issue; - was the U. Virginia
	 shooting that old, or is it some other episode?]
		As they loaded the dead onto the gurneys
		to wheel them from the univesity halls,
		who could have predicted the startled chirping
		in those pockets
	the live cellphones, playing their favourite ringtones, provide a
       	stark contrast to the dead being carried off.]

Elizabeth Bradfield	Phrenology 			21
	[the earth as a skull, being investigated by phrenologists]
Robert Cording		Gift 				32
	[man losing touch, under morpheme for severe back pain, still
	clinging onto every day as a gift.]
Chad Davidson		Labor Days 			34
	[while working at a dress outlet in a stip mall in california, his
	first experience of snow, or is it a flurry of pizza flyers? ]
Stephen Dunn		Aesthete 			36
	[is the wife more important than one's art collection- you wonder as
	a fire rages, which one to save.  an interesting idea, but not as
	strong in the end. ]
Stephen Dunn		To a Friend Accused of a Crime He May Have Committed    37
	[a friend and faculty colleague - has had a secret second life,
	and then it is found while a hard disk is being repaired. eventually
	commits suicide from the exhaust of his car
		When does a friend cease being a friend?
		After which betrayal, yours or ours? ]
Peter Everwine		Rain 				39
	[memories of an old camping trip with father, 60 years back, come
	back in the rain]
Gary Fincke		The Art of Moulage 		40
	[MOULAGE = dummy injuries, skin diseases, used in training.
	Starts w Joseph Towne, who was one of the early makers of moulages
	(was a wax sculptor) - and then to deformities from
	age (his father) or accidents.  In the end,
		    	 "our skin becomes
		A sieve for horror that rises through the pores."]
Gregory Fraser                Silverfish                      42
	[how can one not like a journey through books. As a silverfish, you
	get to roam "bibliographic amphitheaters, thronged with titled
	spines". You slide into "cracks, crevices, bathtubs on
	occasion" - the reader reconstructs a lover being hinted at - she
	takes photographs oblivious of
	her thumb on the lens (how do I know it's a woman? is it my bias that
	a man's less likely to do so?). En route, you get to know that
	Lepisma saccharina is silverfish.  In the end,
		Like every paradise, ideal companionship exists purely
		on the page, is the page. Here. For old times. Feed on this.]
Carol Frost		Apiary XV 			44
	[This poem was all novel juxtapositions, all technical , "ziggurat
	beehive auroras" - without any substance, without any ambition to
	connect to the soul]
Carol Frost		Two Songs for Dementia 		45
	[I didn't get much out of this two part poem, one about a
	bird, and the other about a bear and honey. ]
Allen Grossman                The Garden Oak                  54
	[Come, sit down with me, in this "remembered garden", where the oak
	its oldest tree.  Is it a love lyric, is it just words?  Does it
	matter? Sway with my words, sing with me.  Let it suffuse for a
	while, "then go your way".]
R. S. Gwynn		Body Politic 			56
	[a complex poem, with a rhyming pattern and interesting use of
	parenthetic remarks about body parts and functions.  On the whole an
	analogy of a nation falling apart from inside - rumours, prophecies,
	and then a war or revolution, leading to a joyless end.]
Rachel Hadas		Leaning In 			59
Rachel Hadas		Tu Ne Quaesieris 		61
Mary Stewart Hammond	Facing Eternity 		62
Mary Stewart Hammond	Portrait of My Husband Reading Henry James 	63
Sarah Hannah		Some Pacific Vapor 		65
C. G. Hanzlicek		Dolphin Weather 		66
Bob Hicok		My Stab at Recruiting 		92
Tony Hoagland		Powers 				94
Colette Inez		Looking for Nana in Virginia 	96
Colette Inez		What the Air Takes Away 	97
Roy Jacobstein		Black 				98
Mark Jarman		Fates at Baptist Hospital 	99
Mark Jarman		Haiku 				101
Ted Kooser		110th Birthday 			102
Ted Kooser		Theater Curtains 		103
Ted Kooser		Writing Paper 			104
Jeffrey Levine		A Slight Illumination, a Pacific Vapor 	112
David Mason		From the Anthology 		113
Michael Meyerhofer	The Clay-Shaper's Husband 	115
Robert Mezey		Long Lines, Beginning with a Line Spoken in a Dream 	117
Robert Mezey		The Other Tiger 		118
D. Nurkse		Altamira 			120
D. Nurkse		Bertrand de Born Smuggles a Letter Out of Hell 	121
Alicia Ostriker		The Husband 			123
Alicia Ostriker		Winter Trees 			124
Alison Pelegrin		Tabasco in Space 		138
Catherine Pierce	The Books Fill Her Apartment Like Birds 	141
Catherine Pierce	A Short Biography of the American People by City 	142
Ron Rash		Dylan Thomas 			144
Ron Rash		Shelton Laurel: 2006 		145
Jay Rogoff		Manhattan 			146
Clare Rossini		After a Woodcut of a Medieval Anatomy 	147
Faith Shearin		Each Apple 			149
Faith Shearin		Trees 				150
Maurya Simon		St. Jerome the Hermit 		151
Julie Suk		Flying Through World War I 	182
Anne-Marie Thompson	Babcia 				184
David Tucker		The House 			185
Charles Harper Webb	Three Abominations 		186
Charles Harper Webb	What Kitty Knows 		187
Alan Williamson		For My Mother 			189
Irene Willis		You Want It? 			191

BOOKSHELF
Maryanne O'Hara		rev. of The Monsters of Templeton by Lauren Groff 	198
Dana Levin		rev of. National Anthem by Kevin Prufer 	199
Margot Livesey		rev. of Every Past Thing by Pamela Thompson 	201
Robert Arnold		rev of. Eternal Enemies by Adam Zagajewski 	203

EDITORS' SHELF
Robert Boswell		Rare High Meadow of Which I Might Dream by Connie Voisine 	205
Ron Carlson		A Proper Knowledge by Michelle Latiolais 	205
Jane Hirshfield		The Opposite of Clairvoyance by Gillian Wegener 	205
David St. John		Litanies Near Water by Paula Clausson Buck 	205

EDITORS' CORNER
  		The Reserve by Russell Banks 		206
  		The Soul Thief by Charles Baxter 	206
  		Watching the Spring Festival by Frank Bidart 	206
  		Fire to Fire by Mark Doty 		206
  		Hardheaded Weather by Cornelius Eady 	206
  		Sea Change by Jorie Graham 		206
  		Special Orders by Edward Hirsch 	206
  		Safe Suicide by DeWitt Henry 		206
  		The Third Angel by Alice Hoffman 	206
  		The Kingdom of Ordinary Time by Marie Howe 	206
  		Wrack and Ruin by Don Lee 		207
  		The House on Fortune Street by Margot Livesey 	207
  		God Particles by Thomas Lux 		207
  		Seven Notebooks by Campbell McGrath 	207
  		The Senator's Wife by Sue Miller 	207
  		1940 by Jay Neugeboren 			207
  		That Little Something by Charles Simic 	207
  		Immortal Sofa by Maura Stanton 		207
  		Save the Last Dance by Gerald Stern 	207
  		Our Story Begins by Tobias Wolff 	207
  		Rising, Fall, Hovering by C. D. Wright 	207
CONTRIBUTORS' NOTES
  		Contributors' Notes 			208


amitabha mukerjee (mukerjee [at-symbol] gmail.com) 2010 Jul 16